What Is the Roadmap for Better Parts Pricing?

Chuck Hartle describes pricing improvement as a structured process rather than a one time adjustment. Parts managers first evaluate their current gross performance across customer pay, warranty, and menu priced items to understand where the department stands.

Once the current numbers are clear, the next step involves identifying the true source of margin loss. Raising the matrix alone rarely solves the issue. Many problems originate from manufacturer list price changes or menu prices that never moved while costs increased.

After identifying the cause, managers implement changes through matrix adjustments, menu pricing updates, or both. Communication across departments becomes essential during this stage because service advisors must understand and support pricing changes.

How Often Should Parts Pricing Be Reviewed?

Chuck Hartle explains that many dealerships review pricing only during initial setup or when warranty pricing changes force an update. That approach leaves margin unnoticed for long periods.

Regular review protects profitability. Quarterly reviews represent the minimum standard, while more frequent reviews provide stronger control over customer pay performance.

Are Manufacturer Price Changes Reducing Your Margin?

Manufacturer adjustments can reduce dealership margins. Chuck points out that some OEMs have narrowed the gap between cost and suggested retail on high volume maintenance parts such as oil filters and air filters.

When this occurs, menu pricing that previously produced strong gross may drop into single digit margins. A simple inventory report comparing cost and list price can reveal the impact. According to Chuck, correcting this alone can shift total gross performance by 8–9%.

Should Managers Focus on Matrix Pricing or Menu Pricing?

Matrix pricing plays a role but often affects a limited portion of total customer pay sales. Chuck notes that matrix pricing typically applies to about 10–15% of parts.

The larger opportunity usually sits in menu priced items. High volume maintenance parts often remain priced at outdated levels, producing gross margins as low as 8–15% because prices never changed as costs increased.

Updating menu pricing frequently delivers the largest improvement.

How Do You Identify Margin Leaks?

A practical method involves sorting recent customer pay sales by profit margin and part number. Parts that pull the department below a 25–30% gross range deserve attention.

Many times the solution requires only small adjustments. Incremental changes of 1 or 2 dollars can significantly improve annual profitability without affecting customer perception.

Conclusion

Parts pricing improves through disciplined review and targeted adjustments. Menu pricing, manufacturer list changes, and matrix structure all influence gross performance. Regular analysis of DMS reports helps managers identify weak areas and correct them before margin loss spreads.

The strongest results often come from small changes applied consistently rather than dramatic one time adjustments.

Listen to the episode:

Watch to the episode: